Grassroots Resilience and Resistance

FalunGong_Grassroots-Materials-Site-China__v1.0-1024x440.jpg

Falun Gong practitioners in China prepare leaflets for distribution in their local area.

  • Grassroots campaigns by practitioners and non-practitioners raise awareness

  • Legal complaints filed against Jiang Zemin

  • Global Tuidang (“Quit CCP”) movement denounces CCP violence

  • Bypassing online restrictions to share information using technology

 

In the face of state-sanctioned brutality, Falun Gong practitioners and nonpractitioners alike have responded with peaceful resistance in China. Practitioners in China have been particularly focused on the following initiatives to raise awareness about the persecution, debunk vilifying propaganda, rescue fellow believers and try to help other Chinese distance themselves from the CCP’s brutality.

 

Activism by Falun Gong practitioners in China

 

According to analyses from independent researchers and the U.S. State Department, an estimated 7 million to 20 million people in China practice Falun Gong and actively engage in civil disobedience and grassroots awareness raising. This takes several forms, including: sending reports of rights abuses overseas, sharing information about Falun Gong within China, and XX[AE1] .

 

Documenting accounts of persecution and sending overseas

 

Falun Gong adherents throughout China continue to regularly send detailed reports of the persecution that they or fellow believers have suffered to the outside world through Minghui.org, a website dedicated to reporting on the Falun Gong community worldwide. Despite heavy censorship and risk of reprisals, Minghui and its network of contacts have managed to establish a relatively secure and robust system for documenting abuses and transmitting updates from within China to overseas. From January 2020 to March 2022, approximately 3,000 first-hand reports of the persecution were published on Minghui.[1] These reports include cases related to but not limited to detentions, indictments, sentencing, harassment, death, torture, brainwashing, extortion, and trespassing.

 

Minghui serves as a central communication hub for Falun Gong practitioners around the world to expose the persecution faced inside China and comment on its ramifications. It is the primary site read by Falun Gong practitioners. It is also watched closely by CCP officials, who fear that their names will be documented among those who have abused Falun Gong detainees, potentially resulting in future sanctions.

 

Engaging in grassroots public education

 

Throughout China, Falun Gong practitioners have established 200,000 or more underground printing houses, where they produce leaflets, DVDs, and other materials to expose the persecution and debunk the state’s anti-Falun Gong propaganda. These sites are operated at a grassroots level across China, typically located in the back room of a private residence. Each site provides materials up to 1,000 Falun Gong practitioners, who then distribute the materials in their locales.[2]

 

These numbers indicate millions of Falun Gong practitioners are actively working to expose the widespread suppression they face in China, in what likely constitutes the largest nonviolent, grassroots resistance in the world. How many more people are practicing Falun Gong in China and have not taken part in this form of peaceful resistance is not known.

 

In addition to these campaigns, practitioners inside China have also engineered clever methods to disseminate information, aside from the usual pamphlets and flyers. In some provinces, practitioners use stamps to print “Falun Gong is Good” on dollar bills and banknotes.[3] In urban areas, practitioners have used AirDrop and Bluetooth to send high quality pdfs and images clarifying the state propaganda against Falun Gong to the people riding public transit.[4]

 

Undeterred by their unjustified mistreatment by Chinese authorities, Falun Gong practitioners in detention have continued to inform prison inmates[5], guards, wardens, police officers, police chief[6],  lawyers[7], doctors[8], 610 Office director[9], court judges[10], officials[11], and other staff about the practice and persecution, thereby debunking the CCP’s propaganda and justification for oppressing the spiritual belief. In some cases, adherents and their lawyers have reported members of the security apparatus becoming more sympathetic and even taking steps to reduce the persecution faced by practitioners under their authority.

 

Criminal complaints filed against Jiang Zemin

 

On May 1, 2015, new Supreme People’s Court guidelines took effect that require judicial authorities to accept criminal complaints submitted by individual citizens; previously, they were able to reject such complaints. After a number of articles on Minghui raised awareness of the change, large numbers of Falun Gong torture survivors began lodging criminal complaints that name former CCP leader Jiang Zemin as the one responsible for the persecution and call for him to be investigated.

 

By December 2015, more than 200,000 practitioners in China had filed criminal complaints against Jiang Zemin with their real names for his crimes against humanity.[12] In Shandong Province alone, hundreds of Dafa practitioners have actively participated in the campaign.[13] Many practitioners even took it upon themselves to collect petition signatures in their neighborhoods to sue Jiang. This movement has not been without backlash and reprisals. In one notable case, two women in Chaoyang City were sentenced to prison for filing criminal complaints against Jiang Zemin.[14] Both were pronounced dead in 2020. One of them died six months after being released on medical parole, while the other died three days after being brought home unconscious.

 

“Tuidang” (or “Quit the Party”) movement

 

In 2004, the dissemination of the book “Nine Commentaries on the Communist Party” by Falun Gong practitioners led to the Tuidang (or “Quit the Party”) movement. The publishers of the book encouraged Chinese citizens to make statements of quitting the Party, Communist Youth League, and Young Pioneers (most Chinese people have joined at least one of those at one point in their lifetimes). First-hand accounts by Falun Gong refugees indicate that this movement has become a centerpiece of the community’s grassroots effort.

 

An academic study from 2011 concluded that the Tuidang movement was not an attempt to overthrow the Party, but rather an effort to give Chinese people an opportunity to denounce the CCP’s violence and distance themselves from the authoritarian regime as a way of clearing their conscience and committing to future nonviolence.[15] Many of those who make Tuidang statements do so using aliases, given the risk of retaliation, although some prominent rights activists and others have done so under their real names.[16]

 

Practitioners in China and around the world assist Chinese citizens and members of the diaspora to quit the Party and its affiliated organizations by collecting their renunciations and submitting them to a website outside of China. Since its inception and through March of 2022, the Global Tuidang website had documented 393,744,844 statements of people who had quit the CCP or affiliated organizations. Although this figure could not be independently verified, Chinese court documents from early 2016 identify multiple cases in which Falun Gong adherents were sentenced to prison for possessing tuidang literature, indicating that the CCP itself is taking the movement seriously.

 

Many of those renouncing their affiliation with the CCP admit in their statements to having witnessed or participated in past atrocities. For example, Hu Shuyue from Liaoning Province witnessed the June 4th massacre in 1989. In his statement to quit the CCP and its organizations on January 8, 2020, he relayed the following[17]:

 

After the army crushed the demonstrating students who refused to leave Tiananmen Square with their tanks, the ground was full of corpses and their belongings. The soldiers used trucks to cart away their belongings and helicopters to transport the remains. Then, dozens of fire trucks came to wash the blood off Tiananmen Square, and the authorities forbid anyone from telling the truth. Under military law, anyone who talked would be severely punished.

 

Now that I have been retired from the military for decades, I dare to speak a little bit of truth to Falun Gong practitioners today. I believe what a Falun Gong practitioner has told me about the persecution of her faith and I took her advice to quit the CCP and its organizations. May the Divine bless our lives with peace, fortune, and safety in times of trouble.

 

Support from non-adherents in China

 

For nearly a quarter of a century, Chinese citizens have pushed back against the Party’s narrative of Falun Gong. Ordinary citizens who don’t practice Falun Gong have stepped up and risked their livelihoods to defend the innocent practitioners in their community. Human rights lawyers continue to represent Falun Gong cases, villagers collect hundreds of signatures to release their Falun Gong neighbors, police release or secretly protect arrested practitioners, employers resist government directives to discriminate against Falun Gong employees, family members raise awareness about the unfair treatment against their Falun Gong relative, and the list goes on.

 

Supportive family members

 

The community of practitioners is supported by the larger community they participate in, with the greatest support often stemming from the home. An entire family spanning four generations, with great-grandparents 90 years of age, resisted the Zero-Out campaign since December 2020 and spoke out against the local authorities who visited their home many times to coerce their grandmother and great-grandparents into renouncing their faith.[18]

 

Local residents support Falun Gong neighbors

 

 In August 2020, 415 villagers in Zhangjiakou City, Hebei Province signed an affidavit in support of Yang Jianlu, a Falun Gong practitioner who was arrested and sentenced to eight years for his faith.[19] In the statement, the villagers said:

 

We are all shocked to hear about Yang Jianlu’s arrest. People in nearby villages all know that he practices Falun Gong and is a good person. Whoever needs help, he is always willing to lend a hand. We don’t know much about those sophisticated principles of Falun Gong, but we know that he didn’t do anything wrong by being a good person. He has been detained for nearly eight months. Please release him. Let his family reunite.[20]

 

Similar community affidavits calling on the release of individual practitioners in the past have been signed by 205 villagers in Shandong Province, 1,670 residents in Hunan Province, over 3,000 citizens in Qinhuangdao City, and 5,145 people in Tianjin City.[21] [22] [23] Despite their best intentions, these petitions of support are often met with government efforts to suppress the dissent. Benxi City police checked almost every household to threaten them into retracting their signatures. However, most villagers maintained their support for the detained Falun Gong adherent.[24] One neighbor even said, “If you need signatures again, my entire family will sign!”

 

Human rights lawyers continue to represent Falun Gong clients

 

Since 2003, rights lawyers in China have been defending Falun Gong. Many of the most outspoken ones, such as Gao zhisheng, Wang Quanzhang, or Jiang Tianyong have themselves been detained, tortured, and disappeared. Multiple lawyers have lost their licenses for taking Falun Gong and other human rights cases. In 2020, guidance was issued to lawyers in Jilin Province explicitly telling them not to represent Falun Gong.[25] Nevertheless, over the past two years, other lawyers have continued this effort in spite of the judicial repression of representation for Falun Gong cases.

 

Lawyers across the country still take up the mantle to protect the livelihood, safety, and civil rights of Falun Gong adherents in need. One notable case occurred in Nanchang City, Jiangxi Province, where a retired nurse named Xiong Meiyong was detained for distributing informational materials about Falun Gong.[26] Upon Xiong Meiyong’s release in 2020, her vision had deteriorated due to the torture she experienced in custody. Her house had collapsed while she was in prison and all of her valuables had been stolen. The government also suspended her pension, so she had income. On October 22, 2021, Xiong went to court to appeal for her pension and her lawyer defended her constitutional rights as a retiree. The judge ended up ruling in favor of Xiong, and she was able to receive her pension.

 

These recent trends and incidents match previous documentation by Freedom House, Bitter Winter, and right lawyers’ own accounts and refugee testimony.

 

Police quietly help

 

Some police officers in China have also shown their support by quietly helping out Falun Gong practitioners in crisis. In late 2021, a 70-year old female practitioner went to a supermarket to hand out informational fliers, but was reported to police by high school students and a crowd quickly formed to see the confrontation. But when the police arrived, they just escorted her out of the crowd and reassured her, “Go with us for a while, and then you can just turn the corner and head home.”[27] Also in 2021, when three practitioners were arrested by local police in Shandong Province, one officer persuaded his police director to release them instead of interrogating or detaining them.[28] There are even anecdotes of entire police stations across China, from the bureau director to individual police officers, that refuse to arrest or pressure Falun Gong practitioners.[29]

 

Falun Gong Diaspora

 

For more than two decades, Falun Gong communities and supporters in dozens of countries have mobilized efforts to expose the persecution in China. Those efforts continued in greater numbers over the past two years, and largely consist of:

 

  • Minghui.org: Over the past two decades, Minghui.org editors have received tens of thousands of first-hand reports from across China — more than any other organization in the world. This vast and resourceful network of heroic citizen journalists spans every province in China, and provides day-to-day reports of what’s happening on the ground, often at great risk to themselves. In recent years, Minghui has published more than a dozen first-hand accounts each day from across China, formulating the single largest database in the world of personal accounts from inside China.

  • Phone calls into China: Local volunteer teams across east Asia, the Americas, and Europe call into China, speaking one-on-one with Chinese people about what is really happening to Falun Gong, what lies they are being told over China’s state-run media, and encouraging them to not be complicit in the campaign. These simple phone calls can save the lives of Falun Gong practitioners inside China. During a phone call in early 2020, a Finland practitioner reached the director of a detention center where Falun Gong practitioners were being held. Although the man replied to her with extremely vulgar language at first, she was able to change his mind and after a few days, she received a call from him where he apologized and swore not to persecute Falun Gong adherents in the future.[30] The practitioners held there were released.

  • Capitol Hill events: Parades, candlelight vigils, and briefings to federal officials are annually held by Falun Gong adherents in Washington D.C. to commemorate important dates and remember the lives that have been lost over the course of CCP’s persecution. As the political and symbolic center of the United States, the annual candle vigil is held in front of the Washington Monument every July, held to mourn the victims of the persecution.[31]

  • Protests at Chinese Consulates: During important dates or politically sensitive events, practitioners will hold peaceful protests in front of their local Chinese embassies or consulates. Oftentimes, adherents will also write an open letter about the persecution to the CCP or their local community. On July 6, 2021, Munich practitioners meditated in front of the Chinese Consulate and asked the international community to set aside economic interests and not ignore the persecution.[32]

  • Tabling in tourist areas: From the Eiffel tower in Paris[33], to the National Palace Museum in Taipei[34], and Times Square in New York City[35], Falun Gong practitioners in nearly every country regularly volunteer to have information booths at famous landmarks to raise awareness. Practitioners pass out fliers about the practice, demonstrate the meditation exercises, and display facts about the persecution for all passersby to see.

[1] “Accounts of Persecution,” Minghui, https://search.en.minghui.org/?q=%2A&s=date&c=10&p=138

[2] “Notice: As the Tenth Anniversary of the Minghui Website Draws Near, Editors Answer Readers' Questions,” Minghui, April 22, 2009, https://en.minghui.org/emh/articles/2009/4/22/106718.html

[3] “Falun Gong spreading message on banknotes,” South China Morning Post, February 4, 2009, https://www.scmp.com/article/668802/falun-gong-spreading-message-banknotes

[4] “Chinese Regime Intensifies Persecution of Falun Gong Ahead of Beijing Winter Olympics,” The Epoch Times,  January 8, 2022, https://www.theepochtimes.com/china-exploits-upcoming-winter-olympics-to-tighten-persecution-of-falun-gong-believers_4187704.html

[5] “Everything Changed after Inmates Understood the Truth about Falun Dafa,” Minghui, February 28, 2022, https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2022/2/28/199341.html

[6] “Police Director Regrets Persecuting Falun Gong,” Minghui, November 9, 2021, https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2021/11/9/196518.html

[7] “Busy Saving Sentient Beings in a Detention Center,” Minghui, February 19, 2022, https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2022/2/19/199247.html

[8] “Doctors and Police Officers Witnessed the Power of Dafa,” Minghui, September 8, 2021, https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2021/9/8/194988.html

[9] “610 Office Director Gave Up on Getting Me to Sign a Statement Renouncing Falun Dafa,” Minghui, January 10, 2022, https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2022/1/10/198074.html

[10] “Reminding a Judge of the Law, Minghui,” November 6, 2021, https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2021/11/6/196475.html

[11] “After Listening to the Truth, ‘Zero Out’ Officials Rush to Leave,” Minghui, October 25, 2021, https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2021/10/25/196315.html

[12] “Minghui Annual Report 2015: Wave of Lawsuits Against Jiang Zemin,” Minghui, January 18, 2016, https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2016/1/18/154854.html

[13] “Cooperating as One to Eliminate Evil Display Boards and Banners,” Minghui, March 27, 2022, https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2022/3/27/199686.html

[14] “Two Women Die After Being Imprisoned for Suing Former Communist Party Leader,” Minghui, January 5, 2022,  https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2022/1/5/197993.html

[15] “Tradition and Dissent in China: The Tuidang Movement and its Challenge to the Communist Party,” https://www.allmystery.de/dateien/79056,1337890746,Ford_Caylan2011Tradition_and_Dissent_in_China-_The_Tuidang_Movement_and_its_Challenge_to_the_CP_MA-Thesis.pdf

[16] “Falun Gong: Religious Freedom in China,” Freedom House, https://freedomhouse.org/report/2017/battle-china-spirit-falun-gong-religious-freedom#footnoteref13_moufury

[17] “‘I Am Ashamed of Being a Chinese Communist Party Member’,” Minghui, April 21, 2021, https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2021/4/21/191966.html

[18] “Having Benefited from Falun Dafa, My Whole Family Resists the “Zero-Out” Harassment Campaign,” Minghui, https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2021/10/28/196362.html

[19] “Hebei Man Sentenced to Eight Years, Family Appeals,” Minghui,  https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2021/4/2/191696.html

[20] “Well-regarded Restaurant Owner Sentenced to Eight Years for His Belief,” Minghui,  https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2021/7/24/194250.html

[21] “Shandong Couple Sentenced to Six Years for Their Faith,” Minghui,  https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2020/1/15/182185.html

[22] “Wife Sentenced to Seven Years for Suing Jiang Zemin for Husband's Death While in Custody,” Minghui, https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2020/6/4/185364.html

[23] “China: Thousands of People Sign Two Petitions to Rescue Falun Gong Practitioners Tortured in Binhai Prison,” Minghui, January 10, 2014,  https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2014/1/10/144281.html

[24] “Police Intimidate Residents Who Signed Petition Calling for the Release of Falun Gong Practitioner,” Minghui, https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2015/5/4/150008.html

[25] Falun Dafa Information Center, “Secret File Prevents Lawyers From Defending Falun Gong Cases”, ​​https://faluninfo.net/secret-file-prevents-lawyers-from-defending-falun-gong-cases/

[26] “Order for Falun Gong Practitioner to Return Pension during Her Prison Term Ruled Invalid,” Minghui, December 11, 2021, https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2021/12/11/196953.html

[27] “Police Officers Let a Practitioner Go Home,” Minghui, February 17, 2022,  https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2022/2/17/199222.html

[28] “Kindhearted Police Officer Helps Falun Dafa Practitioners Get Released,” Minghui, November 13, 2021,  https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2021/11/13/196573.html

[29] “Police Officer: ‘I Am Not Going to Interrogate Her Anymore!’,” Minghui, February 3, 2022, https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2022/2/3/199023.html

[30] “A Detention Center Director Apologizes,” Minghui, March 15, 2020, https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2020/3/15/183647.html

[31] “Washington DC: Candlelight Vigil Held to Mourn Victims of 22 Years of Persecution,” Minghui, July 19, 2021, https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2021/7/19/194151.html

[32] “Munich: Protest at Chinese Consulate Exposes CCP’s Ongoing Persecution and Calls for It to End,” Minghui, July 6, 2021, https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2021/7/6/193968.html

[33] “France: Support for Falun Gong at the Eiffel Tower,” Minghui, August 30, 2020, https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2020/8/30/186561.html

[34] “Learning about Falun Gong at the Taiwan National Palace Museum,” Minghui, March 6, 2019,  https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2019/3/6/176052.html

[35] “A Calm Oasis in Bustling Manhattan: People Drawn to Falun Dafa Information Booth at Times Square Summer Expo,” Minghui, September 1, 2021, https://en.minghui.org/html/articles/2021/9/1/194878.html

 [AE1]Is this meant to be another example? Thanks!